Anne Shirley: Ass Kicker

I am an L.M. Montgomery fan.

As in,
I believe I’ve read every single book she wrote,
and loved them all,
in spite of their flaws
(orphan syndrome, sometime suffering from Victorian effusiveness,
similarities in plots).

That caveat aside,
I was doing some serious thinkering today about common heroines
in current YA literature,
and comparing them to Anne Shirley from “Anne of Green Gables”.


They just don’t match up.

Let’s take the current contender for the most popular/well-known
heroine of today:

Bella Swan

She is:

  1. Two dimensional.
  2. Nondescript.
  3. Mediocre.
  4. Places all of her worth on a boy/man/Sparkly Pants McVampire.
  5. Is an ass to her dad without cause.
  6. Apathetic.
  7. Places her intelligence consistently and constantly below everyone else.
    (especially GlitterBoy).
  8. Does not grow.
  9. Ever.

(The Oatmeal says it best…he usually does)
Anne Shirley, on the other hand?

  1. Comes from a background of poverty and abuse, and rises above it.
  2. Refuses to play the victim card.
  3. Works her ass off for everything.
  4. Is dramatic and often temperamental, but does everything she can to exert self-control over this.
  5. Does not place her worth on a man.
  6. Ambitious.
  7. Ridiculously intelligent–but this is developed through the books–she doesn’t start out as a genius.
  8. Goes to college, succeeds through hard work and determination during a time in which higher education was NOT approved of for women.
  9. Marries Gilbert not because he completes her, but because he makes her want to be a better human being.
  10. Marries a man who loves her for her intelligence, beauty, character, and because she makes him want to be a better human being.
  11. Never loses herself when she has children (which is a truly awesome trait that Montgomery invests in her, especially in light of the Victorian Era in which Anne was created).
  12. Her relationships with Marilla, Diana, and Leslie Moore are beautiful
    and real–they have disagreements, fights even, but they come out of them better. There is no cat-fighting bitchery here.
  13. She grows up.

Through seven books, Anne continues to mature and develop as a fantastic heroine–she is the kind of woman who would come running if you needed her.

a character created in the Victorian Era is a better speaker for the rights of women
than a 21st century “liberated” teenager.)
Let me put it this way:

Who would you rather have on your side in The Zombiepocalypse?

Bella Swan would be too busy crying over Pretty Fangs O’busive Boy
to actually, you know, wield something useful, but then again,
she claims to be clumsy–easy Zombie fodder with one simple untied shoelace.


She saves babies from croup, man.
I have no problem believing in her ability to wield a shotgun
all over some zombie ass.

"He called me carrots! So I blew his head off."

(also? I TOTALLY have rights to the Zombie version of “Anne of Green Gables”. Just sayin’.)

5 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. charlotte
    Mar 21, 2011 @ 13:23:32

    Ohmygoodness will you marry me?! In the metaphorical book-loving sense of course. You are my soul mate. I cannot tell you how many conversations I’ve had where I’ve tried to explain to people (esp. the teen girls I teach at my church) that GlitterVamp is NOT romance but is a psycho stalker who rightly should have the cops called on him. And I too love LM Montgomery. I have also read everything she’s ever written and own most of it. Say you love Madeline L’engle too and my heart is yours.


  2. cheekypinky
    Mar 22, 2011 @ 15:16:44

    @charlotte: THANK YOU. The “Twilight” series creeps me out on so many levels, and I just don’t understand how the majority of women can’t see it!

    I do love Madeline L’Engle!

    Charlotte, be mine?



  3. Katherine Hogan
    Mar 24, 2011 @ 10:36:17

    Totally. When I think of the kind of mom I want to be, Anne Blythe is definitely one of the women I pattern myself after. I love that her kids go to sleep thinking they have the best mom in the world, (although I can’t think of the exact quote right now.) Anne is definitely most awesome. And I agree.

    Bella definitely has issues. The Twilight series was entertaining, but I figured out why I hate the second book the most. It really brings out her co-dependency issues, which in turn makes me very uncomfortable. This is why I cannot read YA. I find myself repeating over and over as I throw the book across the room, “JUST GET OVER IT ALREADY!!”

    And what does she do to the guy who snubs her? Wacks him over the head with a slate!! Yes! No moping for one of my favortie heroines!!


  4. Katherine Hogan
    Mar 24, 2011 @ 10:37:24

    Sorry, what does Anne do to the guy who snubs her…


    • cheekypinky
      Mar 24, 2011 @ 18:39:32


      I love love LOVE the picture of motherhood that Montgomery painted–
      Anne isn’t perfect (like the part in “Anne of Ingleside” where she thinks Gilbert no longer loves her and she’s harsh to her kids?), but when she screws up, she acknowledges it; she listens to her children, and never laughs at them. She’s just so well-balanced, you know?

      (and you are already a great mama, by-the-by)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: